Skip to main content

Wie du mir, so ich dir – wann sind Verstösse gegen demokratische Prinzipien vertretbar?

Medienmitteilung, 3. November 2026

Wenn politische Gegner demokratische Grundsätze verletzen, steigt die Zustimmung der eingenen Seite dazu, das gleiche zu tun. Was das für die Demokratie bedeutet, zeigt eine neue Studie unter Mitwirkung von Hannah Werner aus dem Zentrum für Demokratie Aarau.

Heute finden in den USA die Midterms statt. Im Vorfeld der Wahlen liefern sich beide Parteien einen Wettlauf um die Wahlkreisgrenzen: Texas zeichnete seine Karte auf Drängen von Donald Trump neu, Kalifornien zog ausdrücklich als Antwort darauf nach, weitere Bundesstaaten folgten. Beide Seiten argumentieren gleich: Die anderen haben angefangen. Das Prinzip hinter diesem Vorgehen scheint klar: Wenn die Gegenpartei demokratische Regeln verletzt, darf die eigene Seite gleich handeln.

Legitime Vergeltung?

Wie aber beurteilen die Wähler:innen die Strategie ihrer Partei, es der Gegenseite mit gleicher Münze heimzuzahlen? Finden sie es legitim, demokratische Prinzipien zu verletzen, nur weil die politische Gegenseite es auch getan hat? Diese Frage untersucht die neue Studie (siehe unten) mit Mitautorin und Assistenzprofessorin Hannah Werner vom Zentrum für Demokratie Aarau.

In hypothetischen Szenarien zu Wahlrecht, Versammlungs- und Pressefreiheit haben die Autorinnen getestet, ob Menschen von ihrer eigenen Partei undemokratische Schritte verlangen. Also, ob sie etwa Proteste der Gegenseite verbieten oder deren Anhängern das Wählen erschweren sollen. Sie haben auch untersucht, ob sich die Einstellung zu solchen undemokratischen Schritten verändert, wenn sich die Gegenpartei zuerst undemokratisch verhalten hat.

Für Hannah Werner ist die Fragestellen wichtig, weil: «Wir erwarten von Bürger:innen, dass sie unser politische System beschützen wollen und Verstösse gegen demokratische Institutionen bestrafen. Unsere Studie zeigt aber, dass selbst Menschen, denen die Demokratie wichtig ist, unter gewissen Umständen solche Verstösse von ihren eigenen Parteien gutheissen.»

Dynamisch und selbstverstärkend

Das Hauptergebnis der Studie zeigt, dass demokratisches Engagement relational ist. Das heisst: Wenn politische Gegner zuerst demokratische Regeln brechen, unterstützen Bürger:innen Verfehlungen auf ihrer eigenen Seite etwa doppelt so viel. Ohne Provokation befürworten rund 11 Prozent in beiden Ländern solche Schritte. Hat die Gegenseite die Regeln zuerst gebrochen, verdoppelt sich der Anteil: auf 22 Prozent in England und 25 Prozent in den USA. Weiter zeigt die Studie:

  • Am stärksten ist der Effekt beim Wahlrecht: In den USA steigt die Zustimmung, den Anhängern der Gegenpartei das Wählen zu erschweren, von 7 auf 24 Prozent.
  • Es ist kein Phänomen der Hardliner: Der Vergeltungsimpuls ist bei stark und wenig polarisierten Befragten gleich gross, ebenso bei Demokraten und Republikanern, Labour- und Tory-Anhängern.
  • Die meisten begründen ihre Haltung nicht mit Rache (11 Prozent), sondern mit Fairness (68 Prozent): Wer gleichzieht, stelle ein ausgeglichenes Spielfeld wieder her und schütze so die Demokratie.
  • Auch ein Hinweis auf die Bedeutung des betroffenen demokratischen Prinzips dämpfte den Vergeltungsimpuls nicht.

Die Studie zeigt also, wie Regelbrüche weitere Regelbrüche hervorbringen können, gerade bei Menschen, die sich selbst als Demokraten verstehen und grundsätzlich solche Normverstösse ablehnen. Gleichzeitig lehnt auch nach der Provokation eine Mehrheit von rund zwei Dritteln solche Schritte ab. Das bedeutet, dass demokratisches Engagement keine feste Haltung ist, sondern dynamisch auf den politischen Kontext reagiert. Hannah Werner ordnet die Bedeutung dieses Effekts auf die Demokratie so ein: «Dieser Reziprozitäts-Effekt könnte eine gefährliche Abwärtsspirale auslösen, bei der die Gegenseite immer weiter durch Regelbrüche eskaliert – und somit den Abbau von Demokratie politisch möglich macht.»

Daten und Methode

Die Autorinnen der Studie haben Fragebogen-Experimente mit 8000 Menschen in den USA und England im Jahr 2024 durchgeführt. Es wurden hypothetische Szenarien getestet und nicht die eingangs erwähnten aktuellen Ereignisse rund um die Neuzeichnung der Wahlkreise in den USA. Die Daten basieren auf Online-Quotenstichproben von 2024.

Download Studie

Janssen, Lisa; Werner, Hannah and Kern, Anna (2026). “When they go low, we kick them”: The reciprocal nature of citizens’ support for democratic transgressions. The Journal of Politics.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/744129

Kontakt

Prof. Dr. Hannah Werner
hannah.werner@ipz.uzh.ch

Über das ZDA

Das Zentrum für Demokratie Aarau ist ein wissenschaftliches Forschungszentrum, das von der Universität Zürich, der Fachhochschule Nordwestschweiz, vom Kanton Aargau und von der Stadt Aarau getragen wird. Es betreibt Grundlagenforschung und befasst sich mit aktuellen Fragen zur Demokratie – regional, in der Schweiz und weltweit. www.zdaarau.ch

Even those who lose votes stay in the game

Press Release, October 13, 2026

Those who frequently lose in referendums may lose confidence in the Federal Council and Parliament. This is what referendum research to date has shown. However, a new study from the Center for Democracy Studies Aarau now concludes that voters who frequently suffer defeats support direct democracy more and participate more often in referendums, even though their political confidence declines.

The most recent federal referendum on September 27 produced a few losers. Voters clearly rejected both the Neutrality Initiative and the Food Initiative. What happens to citizens who keep losing at the ballot box?

A gap

Research on referendums to date shows that frequent defeats in referendums erode voters’ trust in politics. Consequently, those on the losing side are less satisfied with democracy and trust institutions less than the winners. Repeated defeats exacerbate this loss of trust. However, little research has been conducted to date on how referendum defeats affect individuals in direct democracies. This study, conducted as part of the DDS21 project (see box), fills this gap by examining a political system with extensive direct democracy rather than just individual referendums. This helps us understand how often voters find themselves on the winning or losing side and how these dynamics evolve over the long term.

Losers Stay in the Game

The study examines the effects on trust in political institutions, support for direct democracy, and participation in referendums when votes are frequently lost. Interestingly, only the first concern is confirmed: Those who frequently lose trust the Federal Council and Parliament less than those on the winning side. Even when people frequently suffer referendum defeats, they show greater support for direct democracy and participate more frequently in referendums. Consequently, this means that frequent defeats in a political system where direct democracy is widely used do not automatically lead to disillusionment with democracy among the electorate.

For the study’s author, Laurent Bernhard, the findings mean the following: «In a direct democracy, minorities can repeatedly bring their concerns to the ballot box and hope for success. Moreover, hardly anyone is always on the winning or losing side. This is one of the strengths of direct democracy: the way it functions helps ensure that even those on the losing side remain involved.»

These findings suggest that those who frequently lose in direct democracy are more dissatisfied with the elites than the winners, but are not disillusioned with politics. This supports the view that direct democracy can have a significant integrative effect on those citizens who often do not belong to the winning majority. The study thus suggests that in a political system with numerous referendums, frequent defeats do not necessarily foster political disillusionment.

The «Direct Democracy in Switzerland in the 21st Century (DDS21)» Project

Since 2023, the research project Direct Democracy in Switzerland in the 21st Century (DDS21), funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF), has aimed to examine the reasons behind Swiss citizens’ participation and voting decisions following each federal referendum. Led by the Center for Democracy Aarau (ZDA), which is affiliated with the University of Zurich, DDS21 brings together members from Switzerland’s eight university political science departments as well as the Liechtenstein Institute.

Data and Method
This study used data from a population survey conducted immediately after the federal referendum on June 18, 2023. Based on the sampling register of the Federal Statistical Office (FSO), 2,100 eligible voters participated in an online survey.

Download Study

Bernhard, L., & Kübler, D. (2026). Losing gracefully? On the effects of frequent defeat in direct democracy on political trust, support and participation. Political Research Exchange, 8(1). https://doi.org/10.1080/2474736X.2026.2728513

Contact

Dr. Laurent Bernhard
Project coordinatior Center for Democracy Studies
laurent.bernhard@uzh.ch

About the Center for Democracy Studies

The Centre for Democracy Studies Aarau is a scientific research centre supported by the University of Zurich, the University of Applied Sciences and Arts Northwestern Switzerland, the Canton of Aargau and the City of Aarau. It conducts basic research and addresses current issues relating to democracy – regionally, in Switzerland and worldwide. www.zdaarau.ch

Download the 2026–2029 Development Plan now

«Democracies around the world are facing increasing pressure»

What are the causes of the current crisis in democracy? How does it affect the organization of a state? What does this mean for freedom of speech and assembly, or the separation of powers? These questions lie at the heart of the research conducted at the Center for Democracy Studies in Aarau.

Our new Development Plan for 2026–2029 outlines how our work aims to address these questions. In it, we outline the direction of our research, the partners we collaborate with, and how we are positioned as an interdisciplinary center.

Democracy research across continents

This year’s Swiss Summer School in Democracy Studies saw a significant step toward the internationalization of research collaboration: the University of Zurich (UZH) and the University of Canberra (UC) signed a memorandum of understanding. The agreement marks the beginning of a deeper institutional partnership between the Center for Democracy Aarau (ZDA) and the Centre for Deliberative Democracy and Global Governance at UC.

The cooperation between the two centers goes beyond the Summer School: Close scientific ties already exist today – for example, through reciprocal research visits, joint publications, and international project applications, including to the SNF, Horizon Europe, and the Australian Research Council. The memorandum of understanding now provides a formal basis for this successful collaboration.

Basis for future projects

The agreement was signed in the presence of both partner institutions: Prof. Daniel Kübler (UZH/ZDA) and Prof. Simon Niemeyer (UC) formalized the agreement. The aim is to promote the exchange of researchers and students, to hold joint courses and conferences, and to launch new research projects.

With this MoU, UZH and UC are sending a strong signal for the expansion of international cooperation in democracy research and making an important contribution to networking science and practice in a global context.

Zentrum für Demokratie Aarau, Medienmitteilung, Überdurchschnittliche Mobilisierung der Bürgerlichen bei Aargauer Volksabstimmung

Above-average mobilization of the middle classes in the Aargau referendum

On May 18, 2025, the voters of Aargau approved a revision of the tax law, while the popular initiative «Equal pay in the canton of Aargau – now!» was rejected. It was significant that the middle classes in general and FDP sympathizers in particular took part in the votes. In addition to the left-right divide, trust in the government also played a major role in the tax law. In the case of the equal pay initiative, however, there were clear differences between the genders and age groups. This is shown by the survey on the cantonal referendum on May 18, 2025, which was conducted at the Center for Democracy Studies Aarau.

In the cantonal referendum on May 18, 2025, voters in Aargau approved a revision of the tax law with 54%, while the popular initiative «Equal pay in the canton of Aargau – now!» was rejected with 63%. Voter turnout amounted to just 31.6%, which can be linked to the fact that no votes were held at federal level.

Highest turnout in the ranks of the FDP

In terms of voter turnout, it is worth noting that ideological positioning played a major role: respondents who categorized themselves as right-wing (6-7) or far right (8-10) were more likely than average to vote (41% each). In contrast, slightly fewer than 30 percent of those in the middle of the political spectrum, as well as those on the left and far left, went to the polls. This means that the middle classes were better mobilized than voters in the center and on the left.

Looking at party sympathies, the extraordinarily high proportion in the ranks of the FDP (61%) is striking. No other party supporters took part in the cantonal votes anywhere near as often. In second place were the supporters of the GLP (43%), followed by the center (40%), those of the SP (38%) and the SVP (32%). Of the six largest parties in Aargau, the Greens were the least successful in mobilizing their base (29%). Among those not affiliated to a party, however, less than one in six people entitled to vote took part (15%).

Tax law – also a matter of government trust

Voting behavior on the tax law was strongly influenced by the left-right divide. On the far left, the bill was clearly rejected with a no vote of 81%. In contrast, almost as many on the far right were in favor (69%). The decisive factor in this constellation was the center, where a narrow majority in favor of the revision resulted (55%).

There were also clear differences in support for the tax law according to party affiliation. While the majority of FDP supporters approved the bill (75%), the tax law met with less approval among the other three major parties in Aargau, which had also issued a «yes» slogan. Among sympathizers from the center (60%), the GLP (56%) and the SVP (54%), only narrow majorities resulted in favour of the tax law. A remarkable contrast also emerged in the left-wing camp. In contrast to the supporters of the SP, who clearly rejected the bill (72%), the tax bill was approved by every second person among Green Party supporters (50%).

In addition, the voting decision depended heavily on trust in the government. Those with a high level of trust in the Aargau cantonal government were 72% likely to approve the bill. In contrast, the proportion of those with very low to low trust in the cantonal government was only 28%.

Among the «yes» motives, two considerations were in the foreground: the most common reason given for acceptance was the competitiveness of the canton of Aargau in tax competition (19%). The tax relief for the middle classes was cited almost as often (18%). On the other hand, almost half of those against were primarily bothered by the fact that the wealthy would be favored (47%).

Equal pay initiative – gender and age as key factors

The equal pay initiative revealed striking demographic differences. Gender was the most important factor. Overall, the women who took part were divided. In fact, every second woman was in favor of the popular initiative (50%). In contrast, only around one in four men who took part supported the proposal (27%). Women also attached greater importance to the equal pay initiative than men.

Age also played a major role. In general, approval decreased with increasing age. On the one hand, the clear acceptance among the youngest category of 18 to 29-year-olds (65%) and the clear rejection from the age of 50 are striking. The «yes” share in this segment amounted to less than 30%.

In terms of party sympathies, it can be stated that the equal pay initiative was clearly accepted on the left. A clear majority of Green supporters voted in favor of the proposal (83%), while three out of four SP supporters ultimately voted yes (75%). The supporters of the GLP (34%), the center (34%), the SVP (27%) and the FDP (17%) rejected the popular initiative, which was in line with the party slogans. As with the tax law, the FDP base was characterized by a particularly high degree of unity.

There were two main reasons for rejecting the equal pay initiative: almost one in three people who rejected the initiative stated that there was no need for cantonal regulations if equality laws already exist at federal level. This was followed by concerns about smaller companies that already have a high administrative burden (24%). On the favorable side, the view that equality has not yet been achieved enough was in first place (24%). The need for legal provisions was also important for approval (19%).

Further resources

Bernhard Laurent, Cheon Junmo, Lüscher Sandro, Koelewijn Kymani Shayra, Sorrentino Gianluca, Serdült Uwe. «FOKUS Aargau: Studie zu den Aargauer Volksabstimmungen vom 18. Mai 2025.»FOKUS-Aargau-Berichte, 11. Aarau: Zentrum für Demokratie Aarau (ZDA), Juli 2025. (German)

Contact

Dr. Laurent Bernhard
Project coordinator, Center for Democracy Studies Aarau
laurent.bernhard@uzh.ch

About the CDA

The Centre for Democracy Studies Aarau is a scientific research centre supported by the University of Zurich, the University of Applied Sciences and Arts Northwestern Switzerland, the Canton of Aargau and the City of Aarau. It conducts basic research and addresses current issues relating to democracy – regionally, in Switzerland and worldwide. www.zdaarau.ch

Zentrum für Demokratie Aarau, Medienmitteilung, Politische Meinungsbildung: soziale Medien als Underdog?

Political opinion-forming: social media as the underdog?

Even though political parties spend large sums on social media campaigns during referendum campaigns, Instagram, Facebook, and other platforms are only a key source of information for a few when it comes to voting. How does this fit together? Results from a research project by the Center for Democracy Studies Aarau provide clues and raise questions about the regulation of social media.

One thing is clear: social media still plays a small role in shaping public opinion in Swiss elections. Nevertheless, parties invest considerable sums in social media campaigns during elections and referendums to convince voters of their positions. Data from the post-vote survey on the Environmental Responsibility Initiative (UVI) of February 9, 2025, from the “Direct Democracy Switzerland in the 21st Century (DDS-21)” project (see box) now provide two indications why the role of social media in political opinion-forming in Switzerland should not be underestimated. This also raises the question of social media regulation.

Users today are the young, but they are also getting older

As expected, people aged 18-24 used social media most frequently: First, in the youngest age group, more than a third of voters used social media specifically to inform themselves about the proposal. At the same time, only around 10 percent did not use social media at all. Thus, social media was only crucial for political information in the run-up to votes for a small number of eligible voters. However, because media habits remain relatively stable, this will likely change in the future, giving social media a more important role.

Daniel Kübler, professor at the Center for Democracy Studies Aarau, explains what this means: «Today’s young people frequently use social media. This accessibility also offers political actors the opportunity to reach young voters at an early age and mobilize them for politics.»

Minimum standard for political content

As the importance of social media increases, the question of how to regulate Instagram, Facebook, and other platforms arises. Based on the study’s findings, it can be argued that now is the time to conduct a social and political debate about possible regulations for these platforms. The goal should be to establish minimum standards for political content in order to ensure transparency regarding the financial resources used by political actors.

Gabriel Hofmann, doctoral student and research associate in the project, notes: «A majority of Swiss voters use social media in some form. Even if political content is only in the background, they are accessible to political actors, at least through paid content. Therefore, it is important to know which political actors buy reach and with which criteria.»

If this basic requirement is met, social media can contribute to better information for voters due to their low threshold.

About the project

«Direct Democracy Switzerland in the 21st Century (DDS-21)»
The project «Direct Democracy Switzerland in the 21st Century (DDS-21)» is funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) and examines current issues in voting research. A representative online survey of Swiss voters is conducted after each vote. The project examines four research questions in more detail: How does political advertising influence voters? What does the digitalization of the media landscape, and social media in particular, do to the opinion-forming process? How can political knowledge and political competence be measured? And finally, how are fundamental moral and political values ​​related to voting decisions?

Further resources

Contact

Gabriel Hofmann, doctoral student and research associate at the Center for Democracy Studies Aarau
hofmann@zda.uzh.ch, 062 836 94 57

Prof. Dr. Daniel Kübler, director, Center for Democray Studies Aarau
daniel.kuebler@zda.uzh.ch, 078 815 67 60

About the CDA

The Centre for Democracy Studies Aarau is a scientific research centre supported by the University of Zurich, the University of Applied Sciences and Arts Northwestern Switzerland, the Canton of Aargau and the City of Aarau. It conducts basic research and addresses current issues relating to democracy – regionally, in Switzerland and worldwide. www.zdaarau.ch